Vishwajit Akre of Ranwadi village at his pomegranate farm near Wardha. (Photo by Hiren Kumar Bose)
Pomegranate spells profits for Maharashtra farmers
May 19, 2017
A small pump irrigating an onion farm. (Photo by Hamish John Appleby / IWMI)
Small pumps are a viable solution for poor farmers
May 24, 2017
Big Potential

Small pumps hold promise for smallholder farmers in Jharkhand

Many small and marginal farmers in Lohardaga and Gumla are using tiny pumps to irrigate vegetable fields, an entrepreneurial model that has potential to increase incomes for smallholders since groundwater is abundant in the state
Farmers preparing a small field to grow vegetables in Jharkhand. (Photo by Bikalp Chamola)

Farmers preparing a small field to grow vegetables in Jharkhand. (Photo by Bikalp Chamola)

In Datma village in Kisko block of Lohardaga district in Jharkhand, a lift (device for pumping water, usually of capacity more than 5 horsepower) stands on a small body of water. The lift was meant to cater to the irrigation needs of farmers. The system of operating a lift is simple. One operator is appointed who is given paid a fee for regulatory work that he does. The farmers share the water on an hourly basis, for which they pay rent, during paddy cultivation and the winter season.

Such devices dot the landscape in Lohardaga and Gumla districts of Jharkhand. They came on different subsidies and were either promoted by civil society organizations or by government departments. However, due to irregularity availability of water, the lifts became highly susceptible to preferential water allocation. The farmers with less land and scattered landholdings did not have control over water for irrigation in their fields.

Discriminatory use

Thus, the idea of collective water sharing did not catch the fancy of people in the region, and the lifts were now being by lesser and lesser number of people. As a consequence, in these pockets small pumps made their way into being used as primary devices for irrigation as they provided greater control on water for irrigation to small and marginal farmers.

“We cultivate tomatoes and cabbage thrice in a year to minimize the losses. Even if one crop goes bad, the other two can easily cover up for the same,” said Arjun Prajapati in Aria village of Lohardaga district. “We use smaller pumps because they are cheap. They can run on single phase electric lines too.”

“Earlier we had an electric lift in our village, which stopped working because of lack of maintenance,” said fellow villager Vinod Prajapati. “Usually while growing one crop of tomato on an acre, we expect a gross income of Rs 1 lakh from the same so it makes for a viable income source for us. As more people are now taking up vegetable cultivation because of higher returns, people have started digging tube wells and bore wells.”

In a state where irrigated area for marginal farmers is only 10% of the gross cropped area, although small in number, these farmers stand out as exceptions. In order to understand the use of small pumps in Jharkhand, a study was conducted in districts of Gumla, Lohardaga and Ramgarh and a total of 47 farmers were interviewed.

Graph 1

Shift in cropping pattern

The areas around the town of Bedo have seen an increased interest by farmers in vegetable cultivation. This is due to two reasons — proximity to markets like Ranchi and increased use of shallow groundwater. Also, this could be attributed to the widespread use of smaller capacity pumps, used either on surface sources or to extract groundwater.

These pumps entered irrigation a decade back in the region, due to a subsidy offered initially to farmers on kerosene, which popularized its use in agriculture. However, as the subsidy receded, these kerosene pumps became unpopular, primarily because of the high operational cost. On the other hand, the popularity of small electric pumps was highly dependent on the availability of electric connections in agriculture, and therefore still is limited in a state like Jharkhand. A typical sight during the months of October-November is that of famers carrying small diesel pumps with pipes on the back of their cycles from one place to the other.

The dealers and retailers have reported an increase in the use of electric pumps of late. Diesel and kerosene-run pumps, although popular in areas with no electric connections, provide a disadvantage in terms of high operational cost. Chinese electric pumps, on the other hand, are easily available in the markets of Ranchi, which range from Rs 3,000 to Rs 4,000 (1 HP electric pumps). The most widely used diesel pumps are Honda and Vijay (more than 2 HP), which cost around Rs 10,000. Operation and maintenance for the small pumps is lower compared with their larger counterparts.

No water markets

Although there is an absence of water markets, farmers tend to use water from wells of other farmers for irrigation on an informal basis. In other places, water is extracted with mutual consent of two or more farmers. Pumps, however, are still being used on rent, prices of which remain constant in the village. The rent of the pump per hour is Rs 60-80, where the farmer has to bear the cost of kerosene. To avoid such burden, one farmer ventured into purchasing a secondhand pump for Rs 3000 (3 HP Honda Pump, 4 years old).

Graph 2

Leasing in of land is also a common feature amongst marginal farmers, due to highly scattered land holdings. “I used to migrate earlier to Pune for working as a security guard. But that was not working out, as my family could not move to Pune with me,” Shiv Tehel Singh in Mariyam Toli village of Raidih Block of Gumla district told VillageSquare.in. “Using my own small pump I have been growing vegetables in the last year on my land.” The patterns of sharecropping have also changed in recent years. Marginal farmers are taking in land on lease from lager farmers for cultivating vegetables.

In a village close to Gumla, a farmer was growing potatoes using the water left behind from handpump. He had his kitchen garden close to the community hand pump, and was using a small electric motor to lift the water left behind after cleaning and filling of utensils.

Irrigation intensity

Irrigation intensity for vegetables, being grown during the summer, ranges from 100-150 hours for half an acre of land using the small pumps. Considering a usage of 1 liter of diesel per hour, this would mean a total irrigation cost of Rs 7,000-8,000, for three months. This explains the choice of vegetables being cultivated by the farmers. Tomatoes, especially during March–May yield best results for the farmers. Additionally, pumps are also being used to irrigate crops like paddy and maize during the Kharif season, which otherwise due to lack of sufficient rains might have been spoilt.

The number of tube wells in a vegetable-growing village near Gola has doubled in the last four years. There is a possibility of high renting in of water in the years to come, as some farmers neither have access to groundwater nor means to extract the same, therefore being at a disadvantaged position. All the interviewed farmers did not consider dairy to be an enterprise due to their preoccupation with vegetable cultivation and gathering means for irrigating the same. No one was in mood of growing fodder specifically for feeding cattle, they rather preferred sending them off to nearby grazing lands, opening the gates of another widely common problem in the area — free grazing.

A small pump is in action in Jharkhand. (Photo by Bikalp Chamola)

A small pump is in action in Jharkhand. (Photo by Bikalp Chamola)

Farmers in villages that have a practice of free grazing leave their cattle to graze after the months of the Kharif season. This prevents others who have access to water, to grow crops. Due to free grazing, farmers are not able to cultivate anything during winters, as strict watch is required to stop cattle from entering the field.

Increase in income

Farmers have said that their income from agriculture in the last few years has significantly increased. Almost 60% of the income now comes from vegetables, which are being irrigated using smaller capacity pumps. These are primarily jackfruit, cabbage, cauliflower, tomato, brinjal, cucumber and garlic. In Gola, farmers have stopped cultivating wheat in the last two years, and are growing vegetables. The clusters around Ranchi provide a strong case for entrepreneurial farmers, adopting small pumps on their own, and earning good incomes from vegetables.

What remains to be seen is that given the extreme poverty and distress in the state, can small pumps help small and marginal farmer to regain the control of their own land by accessing abundant groundwater available in the area and earn well in their own villages? Can this small number of farmers cultivating vegetables be seen as evidence for a large potential for the state to become the primary source for vegetables in the urban markets eastern India? Can small pumps, rather than larger pumps, be the engines for ensuring har khet ko pani (water for every field)?

Bikalp Chamola is a researcher with Pune-based Centre for Development Research. He has earlier worked with Rajeevika livelihood mission in Rajasthan. Chamola is a graduate of Institute of Rural Management Anand.

Bikalp Chamola
Bikalp Chamola
Bikalp Chamola is a researcher with Pune-based Centre for Development Research. He has earlier worked with Rajeevika livelihood mission in Rajasthan. Chamola is a graduate of Institute of Rural Management Anand.

6 Comments

  1. […] from an article originally published on VillageSquare.in. Subscribe to VillageSquare’s weekly update on the website for more stories from rural […]

  2. Reality Village says:

    Great Article Mr Bikalp. However some questions are still unanswered from my point of view. Kindly shed some lights on the following questions also:-
    Vegetables are highly perishable item. The loss of vegetables happen at 2 points:- 10-15% is wasted in the land itself while another 5% is wasted during transportation. How this micro form of irrigation is helping in reducing these wastage? Because if this model has to scale, the land under vegetables will increase and this will increase the wastage also.

    Very little has been written about the market linkages of the produces. This form of irrigation will increase the cost of cultivation. How this cost of cultivation is being recovered from the final selling of produce? Where the price of vegetables grown by the mentioned farmers stands in comparison with the existing players in the market?

    The article gives a very good picture of the input side of the agriculture. However, like many other articles, this particular article fails to provide significant light on the market linkage. Believe it or not, no matter how brilliant you input techniques are, but if you have poor market linkage farmers will ultimately dump these.

    Hope you agree with this. Kindly share your inputs.

  3. Simeon V.Liankhankapa says:

    Rural farmers need water for agriculture porposes, small amount project depending on there small amount of there money.

  4. […] Small pumps hold promise for smallholder farmers Many small and marginal farmers in Lohardaga and Gumla are using tiny pumps to irrigate vegetable […]

  5. Uday Prakash Sharan says:

    Many thanks for bringing Jharkhand farmers life .Farmers financials are still worst. 60 % increase in income does not mean they are able to lead decent life. Govt and corporate house of Jharkhand need to do the following to ensure sustainable income to the farmers :-
    1. Value addition facility . For example – Pulp plant where farmers can sell their tomato at reasonable price .
    2. Irrigation infrastructure to ensure lower cost of production as 60 – 70 Rs per hour and diesel cost is ruining farmers .
    If ground water is available I know very efficient and reliable irrigation system working in US.
    3. Marketing of value added products – I had been to lot of grapevine yard in PenYann area 400 miles away from Newyork to understand farmers life . It’s amazing .Each grapevine has a winery and winery testing center. Excellent method to invite Customers close to the product and market the product.
    If we are really concerned and wish to improve agriculture Village Square need to move one step ahead . Collate ideas , form a Team and implement one of two project .
    Uday Prakash Sharan
    upsharan2012@gmail.com
    Address
    AC / 15 / J Eleventh phase
    Adarsh Nagar Sonari
    Jamshedpur
    Jharkhand
    India
    +91 7763811010

  6. Uday Prakash Sharan says:

    Many thanks for highlighting Jharkhand farmers life .Farmers financials are still worst. 60 % increase in income does not mean they are able to lead decent life. In fact their net income has not gone up . Govt and corporate house of Jharkhand need to do the following to ensure sustainable income to the farmers :-
    1. Value addition facility . For example – Pulp plant where farmers can sell their tomato at reasonable price .
    2. Irrigation infrastructure to ensure lower cost of production as 60 – 70 Rs per hour and diesel cost is ruining farmers .
    If ground water is available I know very efficient and reliable irrigation system working in US.
    3. Marketing of value added products – I had been to lot of grapevine yard in PenYann area 400 miles away from Newyork to understand farmers life . It’s amazing .Each grapevine has a winery and winery testing center. Excellent method to invite Customers close to the product and market the product.
    If we are really concerned and wish to improve agriculture Village Square need to move one step ahead . Collate ideas , form a Team and implement one or two project as model projects to uplift rural India .
    Uday Prakash Sharan
    upsharan2012@gmail.com
    Address
    AC / 15 / J Eleventh phase
    Adarsh Nagar Sonari
    Jamshedpur
    Jharkhand
    India
    +91 7763811010